Garage Flooring Rolls vs Mats: Which is Better Garage Floor Covering?
When choosing between garage flooring rolls and mats, understanding the key differences can help you make the best decision for your space.
Both garage flooring rolls and mats offer protection and improve the look of your garage, but they serve different needs. Flooring rolls provide seamless coverage, ideal for large areas, while mats offer flexibility and easy installation.
Whether you prioritize durability, ease of cleaning, or cost, this comparison will guide you through the pros and cons of each option to help you choose the right solution for your garage.
What Are Garage Flooring Rolls?
Garage flooring rolls are large sheets of material, designed to cover and protect the concrete floors of garages. They are typically made from:
- rubber,
- PVC, or
- vinyl.
They are a popular choice for homeowners who want to enhance the look and functionality of their garage without the need for extensive installation work.
These rolls are easy to install, usually requiring just unrolling and cutting to fit the space, and can be placed directly over the existing concrete floor.
One of the primary benefits of garage flooring rolls is their ability to protect the floor from stains, spills, and wear caused by:
- vehicles,
- tools, and
- other heavy equipment.
They also provide a non-slip surface, which is particularly important in a space where oil, water, or other liquids might be present.
In addition to protection, these rolls can enhance the garage’s aesthetics, offering a clean, polished look.
They come in various colors and patterns, including coin, diamond, and ribbed textures, allowing for customization based on personal preferences.
If you’re in a colder climate, PVC garage flooring rolls act as a barrier against the cold concrete, making your garage more comfortable. They also reduce noise, which is a bonus if you spend a lot of time in your garage.
What Are Garage Flooring Mats?
Garage flooring mats are protective coverings designed to safeguard the garage floor from damage while also enhancing safety and comfort.
Made from durable materials such as rubber, PVC, or vinyl, these mats are typically smaller than flooring rolls and are used to cover specific areas within the garage, such as under vehicles or workspaces.
Their primary function is to protect the concrete floor from the wear and tear caused by:
- heavy vehicles,
- tools, and
- chemical spills.
This is particularly important in garages where vehicles are parked or maintenance work is regularly performed. Mats can also protect against tire marks and the impact of dropped tools, preserving the floor’s appearance and integrity.
In addition to protection, garage mats contribute to safety within the garage. Many mats feature textured surfaces that provide traction, reducing the risk of slipping on wet or oily floors. This is crucial in an environment where spills are common.
Some mats are specifically designed to contain liquids, further enhancing safety by preventing puddles and keeping the garage floor dry.
Comfort is another significant advantage of garage flooring mats, especially for those who use their garage as a workspace. Standing on hard concrete for extended periods can be uncomfortable and even lead to fatigue.
Cushioned mats offer a more comfortable surface, making tasks like car maintenance or woodworking more enjoyable and less physically taxing.
Aesthetically, garage flooring mats can transform the appearance of a garage. Available in a wide range of designs, colors, and patterns, they allow homeowners to customize the look of their garage to match their personal style.
Whether opting for a sleek, modern design or something more rugged, mats can enhance the overall visual appeal of the space while serving a functional purpose.
Types Of Garage Rolls
With various types of garage flooring rolls available, you can find options that suit different needs, climates, and budgets. Here’s a few:
PVC Garage Rolls
These rolls are known for their durability and resistance to chemicals, oil, and water. They’re perfect for high-traffic areas and garages where you work on vehicles. PVC rolls are also slip-resistant, making them a great option for safety.
They come in a variety of patterns and colors, including the popular diamond plate design, which provides extra traction. You can easily clean them with a broom or a mild soap and water solution, making maintenance a breeze.
Rubber Garage Rolls
If you’re looking for something more cushioned, rubber flooring rolls might be your go-to. Rubber garage flooring is ideal if you use your garage as a home gym or workshop where you spend a lot of time on your feet.
It provides excellent shock absorption and sound dampening. Rubber mats are durable, but they can react to certain chemicals and oils, so it’s essential to ensure that the rubber is either virgin or vulcanized if you plan to park vehicles on it.
Rubber rolls are heavier and may require more effort to install, but they provide long-lasting comfort and durability.
Vinyl Garage Rolls
Vinyl garage flooring rolls are another excellent option. These rolls offer many of the same benefits as PVC rolls but are often more affordable. Vinyl rolls are easy to install, usually requiring only a sharp utility knife for custom cuts.
They’re also resistant to liquids, making them ideal for garages prone to spills. Vinyl garage rolls can be installed with double-sided tape to keep them in place, although many are heavy enough to stay put on their own.
The rolls expand and contract with temperature changes, so it’s important to leave a little room near the walls during installation.
Containment Mats
For those in snowy climates, containment mats are a specialized type of roll-out garage flooring designed to trap water, slush, and other debris. These mats have raised edges to contain liquids, preventing them from spreading across your garage floor.
This is particularly useful if your garage doesn’t have a drain. The mats are easy to clean, and some models even allow you to remove the edges to squeeze out the water. These are a must-have if you want to protect your garage floor from winter weather damage.
Interlocking Tiles
If you need something more customizable, interlocking tiles made from PVC or rubber offer flexibility. They are not traditional rolls, but they provide a modular approach to covering your garage floor.
You can mix and match different colors and patterns to create a unique look. They’re easy to install and expand, making them an excellent choice if you plan to adjust your setup over time.
Nitro Rolls
Nitro rolls are another interesting option. These rolls are known for their high durability and are often used in commercial garages or trailers.
They offer superior traction and are resistant to stains and chemicals. Nitro rolls are a bit more expensive but are worth the investment if you need something heavy-duty.
Remember, each type of roll offers unique benefits, so think about your specific needs and the conditions in your garage. By selecting the right garage flooring roll, you’ll protect your garage floor and enhance the space’s functionality and aesthetics.
Types Of Garage Flooring Mats
Like rolls, you also have many options for garage flooring mats. Here’s a few popular ones:
Rubber Garage Mats
Rubber garage mats are a popular choice for their durability and versatility. They’re great for garages that double as home gyms or workshops.
The cushioning effect of rubber mats provides comfort when standing for long periods and helps reduce noise. These mats are slip-resistant, making them safe for wet or greasy environments.
Rubber mats are also easy to clean; just sweep them with a broom or hose them down. However, be aware that not all rubber mats are created equal. Some are made from rebonded rubber, which can break down when exposed to oil and chemicals.
If you’re planning to park your car on it, opt for virgin or vulcanized rubber mats that resist such damage.
Vinyl Garage Mats
Vinyl garage mats offer a sleek and durable solution for protecting your garage floor. These mats are resistant to liquids, making them ideal for areas where spills are common.
Vinyl mats are also slip-resistant, ensuring safety while working in the garage. They come in various patterns and colors, such as diamond plate and coin designs, adding a stylish touch to your garage.
One of the biggest advantages of vinyl mats is how easy they are to install. You can cut them to size with a utility knife, and they lay flat without much effort.
Cleaning is just as simple—sweep or mop with a mild soap and water solution, and your vinyl mat will look as good as new.
Containment Mats
If you’re dealing with snow, rain, or other wet conditions, containment mats are a must-have. These mats are designed to trap water, slush, and other debris, preventing it from spreading across your garage floor.
Containment mats have raised edges that keep liquids contained, making them a practical choice for winter months. They’re especially useful if your garage doesn’t have a drain.
Cleaning them is straightforward; you can use a wet vac or squeegee to remove the water. Some models even allow you to remove the edges, making it easier to get rid of the collected liquid.
Fabric Garage Mats
For those who want a softer, more comfortable surface, fabric garage mats are a unique option. These mats are made from artificial fabric that’s designed to be waterproof and resistant to oil and chemicals.
They’re perfect for creating a comfortable workspace or a slip-resistant surface in the garage. Fabric mats are easy to clean, and their sound-absorbing properties make them a great choice if you spend a lot of time working in the garage.
However, make sure your garage is well-ventilated and heated, as these mats can trap moisture if not properly maintained.
Loose Lay Garage Mats
If you need something portable, loose lay mats are a good option. These mats aren’t permanently attached to the floor, making them easy to remove and clean outside.
Loose lay mats can be interlocking tiles or roll-out mats that you can move around as needed. They’re perfect if you want the flexibility to change your garage layout or need a temporary solution.
Adhesive Mats
For a more permanent installation, adhesive mats offer a secure fit that won’t shift underfoot. These mats are bonded to the floor with adhesives, ensuring they stay in place no matter what.
Adhesive mats are ideal for garages with heavy vehicles or frequent use. Keep in mind that proper floor preparation is necessary for a strong bond, and removing these mats can be challenging.
No matter what type of garage mat you choose, you’ll be adding protection and style to your garage floor. Whether it’s vinyl for ease of cleaning, rubber for comfort, or a containment mat for winter protection, there’s a garage mat designed to fit your specific needs.
Pros & Cons Of Garage Flooring Rolls
Pro: Easy To Install
One of the biggest advantages of garage floor rolls is how easy they are to install. You can simply unroll them, cut them to fit with a utility knife, and you’re good to go.
Whether you’re covering the entire garage or just a portion, garage rolls are also easy to customize. There’s no need for complicated tools or professional help, which can save you both time and money.
Double-sided tape can help keep them in place, but many rolls are heavy enough that they stay put without it.
Pro: Durability
When it comes to durability, garage flooring rolls stand out. These rolls are resistant to stains, chemicals, and liquids, making them perfect for garages that see a lot of spills.
Whether you’re dealing with oil from your car or water from a winter’s worth of snow, flooring rolls provide a protective barrier for your garage floor. They’re also easy to clean.
A broom and a mild soap and water solution are usually all you need to maintain them. This makes them ideal if you want to keep your garage looking sharp with minimal effort.
Pro: Anti-Slip Properties
Another advantage of garage flooring rolls is their anti-slip properties. Coin and diamond plate patterns offer extra traction, which is especially useful in wet conditions.
If you’re using your garage as a workshop or home gym, these rolls provide the slip resistance you need to stay safe. Plus, they help dampen noise, making the space more comfortable to work in.
Con: Prone To Expand & Contract
On the downside, some garage floor rolls can be prone to expanding and contracting with temperature changes. This can cause them to curl at the edges or shift slightly, especially if not installed properly.
If your garage experiences extreme temperatures, you might notice this more. Leaving a small gap between the mat and the wall can help accommodate these changes.
Con: Cheap Ones Can Be Nasty
Another potential con is that not all rolls are created equal. Cheaper options might not have the durability you need, especially in high-traffic garages.
Rubber flooring rolls, for example, can degrade if exposed to certain chemicals or oils. Make sure you’re choosing the right material for your specific needs.
Some rolls can also be a bit tricky to clean, especially if they have deep patterns that trap dirt and debris. While they’re easy to maintain on the surface, you might find yourself needing to give them a more thorough clean every now and then.
Pros & Cons Of Garage Flooring Mats
Pro: Easy To Install
One of the major advantages of garage floor mats is how easy they are to install. You don’t need special tools or professional help—just unroll the mat, cut it to size with a utility knife, and you’re done.
If you’re covering a smaller area or just want to protect the floor under your car, garage mats are a quick and cost-effective solution. You can also move them around or take them outside for cleaning, which adds to their convenience.
Pro: Tough
When it comes to durability, mats made from PVC or vinyl are a good choice. They’re resistant to chemicals, oils, and other liquids, which can help protect your garage floor from stains and damage. Mats like these are also easy to clean.
A broom or mop with mild soap and water is usually all it takes to keep them looking fresh. This ease of cleaning is particularly useful if your garage sees a lot of messy work.
Pro: Grip & Traction
Garage mats also offer excellent traction. With anti-slip surfaces, you’re less likely to slip, even when the floor is wet. This makes them a safer option, especially in garages that double as workshops or gyms.
The added traction also helps protect your floor from the wear and tear of daily use.
Con: Can Shift Or Curl
On the downside, garage mats can sometimes shift or curl, especially if they aren’t installed securely. This is more likely to happen in high-traffic areas or if the mat isn’t heavy enough to stay in place.
Some people use double-sided tape to keep the edges down, but this can be a hassle if you need to move the mat frequently.
Con: Long Term Durability
Another potential issue is that some mats, particularly rubber ones, may not hold up well under certain conditions. For example, rubber mats can degrade over time if exposed to oil or chemicals.
If you park your car in the garage, a rubber mat might not be the best choice unless it’s specifically designed for that purpose.
Vinyl mats, on the other hand, are generally more resistant to these issues, but they might not provide the same level of cushioning.
Con: Moisture Buildup
One thing to watch out for is moisture buildup. Some mats, particularly those made from fabric, can trap moisture if your garage isn’t well-ventilated. This can lead to mold or mildew over time.
If you live in a humid climate, you might want to consider mats that are designed to handle moisture better.
Garage Rolls Installation Process
Installing garage flooring rolls is a straightforward process that can transform your garage in just a few hours. The easy-to-install nature of these flooring rolls makes them a popular choice for many homeowners.
You don’t need any special tools or professional help, just a little preparation and some basic supplies.
- Clean your garage floor thoroughly. Sweep away any dirt, dust, or debris with a broom, and if needed, use a mild soap and water solution to remove stains or liquid spills. The cleaner your floor, the better your vinyl garage flooring will adhere and lay flat.
- If you’re dealing with tough spots, a cleaner like Purple Power can help break down any stubborn grime.
- Once the floor is clean and dry, you’re ready to unroll your garage floor covering.
- If your roll has been stored for a while, you might notice that the edges curl out of the roll. Let the material relax for a bit before positioning it.
- You can cut garage mats to fit your space with a sharp utility knife. It’s important to leave a small gap between the garage roll and the walls.
- This allows the material to expand and contract with changes in temperature without causing wrinkles or buckling.
- For added security, especially in high-traffic areas, you can use double-sided tape around the edges to keep the flooring rolls in place. However, most roll-out garage flooring options are heavy enough that they don’t need extra adhesives.
- Once the mat is in position, you’re all set.
If you’re using a patterned mat, like a diamond plate or large coin design, make sure the patterns align across the whole garage for a clean, professional look.
Garage Mat Installation Process
- Start by cleaning your garage floor. Sweep away dirt and debris with a broom, and if necessary, use a mild soap and water solution to remove any stains or liquid spills.
- Once your floor is clean and dry, unroll your garage mat.
- If you need to fit the mat to a specific area, you can cut garage mats with a sharp utility knife. Leave a small gap between the mat and the walls of your garage.
- This allows the mat to expand and contract with changes in temperature without buckling.
- In high-traffic areas, you might want to use double-sided tape to secure the edges. This is especially helpful if your garage experiences a lot of movement, like a home gym or workshop area.
- If you’re using a patterned mat, like diamond plate or large coin, make sure the design aligns for a cohesive look across your garage floor covering.
- Once in place, your garage mat is ready to use.
Garage Floor Carpeting
You are maybe thinking of using ordinary carpets in the garage. Floor carpets in the garage may be aesthetically pleasing, but it’s a bad idea even if the carpets are old and you want to get some last use out of them. Ruining new carpets in the garage is not recommended either.
Regular carpets don’t last long in the garage. Oil, dirt, water, road salt, chemicals, and dust will quickly ruin regular floor carpets. Household carpets are also a fire and slip hazard and should never be used in the garage. Only use artificial fabric mats designed for garage usage.
Carpeting the garage with regular floor mats is the worst garage flooring decision you can make!
Regular carpets will absorb everything quickly because of the fabrics used in the carpet. Garages often have many usages, and dirt comes from cars, foot traffic, and outside when the garage door is open. Rugs are also hard to clean, and oil stains will ruin them for good.
Carpets absorb water and moisture also and dry very slowly. With moisture, you get mold and mildew too. Regular floor carpets will also wear and tear fast in the garage environment. Fabrics used in the carpet are also a fire hazard. Adding oil, grease, and chemicals, you have highly flammable accidents just waiting to happen.
Read about garage hazards here.
Regular carpets also don’t stay in place easily, and you might slip and hurt yourself badly.
Carpeting the garage might be fine if you only use the garage as a man cave, home office, or similar light usage. Not involving anything that could ruin the carpets or your safety.
Using regular floor carpets in the garage is a bad idea, and you have lots of better options for garage flooring.
Garage Flooring Rolls vs Mats: Pick What Suits Your Needs
Choosing between garage flooring rolls and mats ultimately depends on your specific needs, budget, and how you use your garage.
Rolls offer comprehensive coverage and durability, making them ideal for larger spaces and high-traffic areas. Mats, on the other hand, provide flexibility and are easy to install and move. Both options can protect your garage floor and enhance its appearance.
By weighing the pros and cons of each, you can find the best flooring solution to suit your garage’s unique requirements.
